Malignant Melanoma: Total Body Skin Exams Save Lives and Suffering
Unfortunately, we have evolved a paradox in this country with few doctors well versed in detecting melanoma. Certainly dermatologists are far and away the most competent diagnosticians of this horrible disease, yet dermatologists see the fewest numbers of patients. In addition most dermatologists are busy and don't want to do full body exams and most patients don't want their dermatologist to examine their whole body. To that we add a generalized paranoia on the part of physicians and patients. Patient paranoia is based on fear of missing the significance of a changing mole. Physician paranoia is based on the fear of being sued. Together they have created an environment in which tens of thousands of normal moles are removed each year and still the patients don't undergo full body exams. Since fully 50% of melanomas may not arise from a pre-existing mole and since needless removal of moles causes disfiguring scarring we have created a self-righteous monster in which patients and doctors are smug about poor medical care.
A case in point: A mother brought her 16 year-old son to see me to check his moles. I found 5 scars on his body. The mother told me the scars were from removing moles that looked suspicious. Oh, I said, "and how many of these moles were cancer?" "None", she replied. "Well". I said, "that proves your doctor is 100% accurate. Every time she thinks a mole is suspicious it is not cancer. How many more moles will you remove from your son before you consult a second opinion?" The moral to the story is competent dermatologists know when to biopsy and when to watch. Needless disfigurement does not reduce the incidence of malignant melanoma. A second opinion never hurts.

